Pumpkin fondue

A whole pumpkin baked full of mushrooms, chestnuts, three cheeses and béchamel, then brought to the table to scoop out with its soft flesh and spread on toast, with cornichons.

From Meera Sodha, the Guardian: Pumpkin fondue. Rewritten in my own words.

In development: changed, not cooked as written yet47 amounts, times and temperatures are estimates, marked est. where they appear. Tap one to see why.
Serves
8 for dinner, with bread, pickles and salad
Takes
3h 35 min, start to serving
Hands-on
about 2h 10 min, plus 58 min with a pan or the oven to watch
Oven
200°C (180°C fan)

Not yet confirmed

No source or cook has confirmed these yet, so watch them as you cook.

  • How much of the filling and béchamel the cavity takes: by my sums about a litre of the 1.3 litres, with the rest in the small dish (Fill the pumpkin)
  • That the wrapped pumpkin holds its heat for half an hour if people are late: my estimate (Bake the pumpkin in foil)
  • How long it takes in foil: the source gives 1–1¼ hours for 3kg, but one dense 3kg pumpkin may need longer, and two medium ones may be done from 50 minutes (Bake the pumpkin in foil)
  • Making the onion and mushroom mix the day before: my suggestion, not the source's (Cook the onion and chestnuts)
  • Three baguettes, a jar of cornichons and two bags of salad for 8: my estimates

When to make each part

Latest start to servingCan start this much earlierHands-on, at a set timeHands-on, any time in this range

  • Mushroom and cheese fillingStart by 3h 35 min before serving, 1h 9 min hands-on, keeps 2 hours.
  • The pumpkinStart by 3h 19 min before serving, 31 min hands-on.
  • BéchamelStart by 2h 11 min before serving, 15 min hands-on.
  • To serveJust before serving, 14 min hands-on.

This is one possible order. Each step only has to come after the steps it uses.

  1. Cook through to serving

    Mushroom and cheese filling. Start at least 3h 35 min before serving. Keeps 2 hours, covered, so it can be made ahead.Estimate. An hour or two covered, once the cheese is in.

    1
    Mushroom and cheese filling. At the latest 3h 35 min before serving

    Chop the onion

    Peel and finely chop the 1 onion.

    Aim: Chopped onion.

    board4–6 minEstimate. One large onion, finely chopped.hands-on

    Pause point: it keeps 2 hours.Estimate. Prepared ingredients keep a couple of hours, covered.

  2. 2
    Mushroom and cheese filling. At the latest 3h 29 min before serving

    Mince the garlic

    Peel and mince the 3 garlic cloves.

    Aim: Minced garlic.

    board2–3 minEstimate. Three cloves.hands-on

    Pause point: it keeps 2 hours.Estimate. Prepared ingredients keep a couple of hours, covered.

  3. 3
    Mushroom and cheese filling. At the latest 3h 26 min before serving

    Chop the chestnuts

    Chop the 80g cooked chestnuts.

    Aim: Chopped chestnuts.

    board1–2 minEstimate. A handful, roughly chopped.hands-on

    Pause point: it keeps 2 hours.Estimate. Prepared ingredients keep a couple of hours, covered.

  4. 4
    Mushroom and cheese filling. Any time from 3h 35 min to 3h 24 min before serving

    Pick the thyme

    Pick the leaves from the 12 thyme sprigs; you want about 1 tablespoon.

    Aim: Thyme leaves.

    board3–5 minEstimate. Twelve sprigs by hand.hands-on

    Pause point: it keeps 2 hours.Estimate. Prepared ingredients keep a couple of hours, covered.

  5. The pumpkin. Start at least 3h 19 min before serving.

    5
    The pumpkin. Any time from 3h 35 min to 3h 19 min before serving

    Open and season the pumpkin

    Set the 3kg Crown Prince, Delica or kabocha squash on a damp tea towel so it can't roll. With the small serrated knife, saw a lid about 15cm wide off the top in short strokes (a little smaller for two medium ones), and keep it. Scoop the seeds and strings out of the pumpkin and off the underside of the lid. Cut a little extra flesh from the cavity walls with a metal spoon to open it up, leaving them 2cm thick or more, and chop a handful of it small, like the onion, for the filling. Pour in water from a measuring jug to see what it holds: about a litre takes most of the filling, and the rest bakes in the small dish. Tip the water out and pat the inside dry. Lay two long sheets of foil crossways in the roasting tin, set the pumpkin on them and rub the inside with the 15ml olive oil, 1.5g fine salt and 1g mixed spice.

    Aim: Hollowed out through a wide lid, seasoned inside.

    Ready when no seeds or strings left, the opening is wide enough to spoon the filling in, and the cavity holds about a litre.

    ovenproof dish15–20 minEstimate. A hard squash's lid takes most of the source's 15 minutes of prep; checking the size and chopping the scraped flesh add a few more.hands-on

    Pause point: it keeps 4 hours, covered.Estimate. Raw, seasoned squash keeps a few hours covered.

    Watch Angle the knife towards the centre as you cut the lid, so it sits on the rim later instead of falling in.
    If it goes wrong If the knife sticks, don't lever it; wiggle it out and start again a little further round. If the lid breaks, cover the opening with a double layer of foil instead.
  6. 6
    Mushroom and cheese filling. Any time from 3h 35 min to 2h 59 min before serving

    Chop the mushrooms

    Tear the 500g mixed mushrooms (oyster, shiitake, chestnut or wild) into shreds, or chop them small.

    Aim: Chopped mushrooms.

    board10–15 minEstimate. 500g by hand.hands-on

    Pause point: it keeps 2 hours.Estimate. Prepared ingredients keep a couple of hours, covered.

  7. 7
    Mushroom and cheese filling. Any time from 3h 35 min to 2h 44 min before serving

    Chop the Gruyère

    Roughly chop the 100g Gruyère.

    Aim: Chopped Gruyère.

    board2–3 minEstimate. A small block, roughly chopped.hands-on

    Pause point: it keeps 2 hours.Estimate. Prepared ingredients keep a couple of hours, covered.

  8. 8
    Mushroom and cheese filling. Any time from 3h 35 min to 2h 41 min before serving

    Grate the Emmental

    Grate the 75g Emmental.

    Aim: Grated Emmental.

    board2–3 minEstimate. A small block on a box grater.hands-on

    It can wait 4 hours.Estimate. My estimate of how long this holds once prepared, covered.

  9. 9
    Mushroom and cheese filling. Any time from 3h 15 min to 2h 38 min before serving

    Cook the onion and chestnuts

    Have ready: the chopped onion, the pumpkin offcuts, the minced garlic, the chopped chestnuts and the thyme leaves.

    Heat the 45ml olive oil in the large sauté pan, add the chopped onion and the pumpkin offcuts and cook for 6–7 minutes, until soft. Add the minced garlic, the chopped chestnuts, the thyme leaves and 1g mixed spice, cook for 2 minutes more, then scrape it all into a large bowl.

    Aim: Soft, sweet onion and pumpkin with garlic, chestnuts and thyme.

    Ready when the onion is soft and the garlic smells cooked, not raw.

    Not yet confirmed: Making the onion and mushroom mix the day before: my suggestion, not the source's.

    frying panhob, medium heat8–9 minhands-on

    Pause point: it keeps 3 hours, covered.Estimate. A few hours covered on the counter on the day; or make it the day before and chill it.

  10. 10
    Mushroom and cheese filling. Any time from 3h 20 min to 2h 29 min before serving

    Cook the mushrooms dry

    Have ready: the chopped mushrooms.

    Heat the 45ml olive oil in the same pan, add the chopped mushrooms, 3g fine salt and black pepper (about six grinds), turn the heat up high and cook, stirring now and then, until no liquid is left, about 15 minutes. Tip them into the bowl with the onion.

    Aim: Mushrooms cooked until dry and browned in places.

    Ready when no liquid left in the pan; it sizzles rather than bubbles, and the mushrooms are browned at the edges.

    frying panhob, high heat15–18 minhands-on

    Pause point: it keeps 3 hours, covered.Estimate. A few hours covered on the counter on the day; or make them the day before and chill them.

    Watch They give off a lot of water first; keep the heat high until it has gone.
    If it goes wrong If they're still wet after 18 minutes, spread them out and keep the heat high. Wet mushrooms make a watery fondue.
  11. Béchamel. Start at least 2h 11 min before serving. Keeps 30 minutes, with baking paper pressed on the surface, so no skin forms.

    11
    Béchamel. Any time from 3h 8 min to 2h 11 min before serving

    Make the béchamel

    Melt the 50g unsalted butter in a saucepan over a medium heat. When it froths, add the 50g plain flour and 1.5g fine salt and whisk for a couple of minutes, until smooth. Pour in the 500ml whole milk slowly, whisking all the time, until the sauce thickens, then let it bubble gently for 3–5 minutes more, still whisking, and take it off the heat.

    Aim: A smooth, thick white sauce.

    Ready when thick like custard, it holds a trail across the surface and tastes of milk, not raw flour.

    saucepanhob, medium heat12–15 minEstimate. A couple of minutes for the flour, as the source says, about 6 for the milk, then a few minutes' bubbling so it doesn't taste of flour.hands-on
    Watch Add the milk a little at a time at first, whisking out each lump before adding more. It thickens all at once near the end, so whisk into the corners.
    If it goes wrong If it's lumpy, whisk it hard off the heat, or blitz it with a stick blender. If it's too thick to pour by the time you fill, whisk in a splash of milk over a low heat.
  12. 12
    The pumpkin

    Heat the oven

    Heat the oven to 200°C (180°C fan).

    15 min
  13. 13
    Mushroom and cheese filling. Any time from 3h 35 min to 1h 53 min before serving

    Chop the Stilton

    Roughly chop the 50g Stilton or another blue cheese.

    Aim: Chopped Stilton.

    board1–2 minEstimate. A small piece.hands-on

    Pause point: it keeps 2 hours.Estimate. Prepared ingredients keep a couple of hours, covered.

  14. 14
    Mushroom and cheese filling. Any time from 3h 2 min to 1h 51 min before serving

    Fold in the cheese

    Have ready: the onion and chestnut mix, the cooked mushrooms, the chopped Gruyère and the grated Emmental.

    Fold the chopped Gruyère, 50g of the grated Emmental and the chopped Stilton through the onion and mushrooms. Keep the rest of the Emmental for the top.

    Aim: The onion, mushrooms and three cheeses folded together.

    bowl2–3 minEstimate. My estimate.hands-on
  15. 15
    The pumpkin. Within 30 minutes of finishing “Make the béchamel”

    Fill the pumpkin

    Have ready: the béchamel.

    Spoon the filling in loosely until it's nearly full; if you're using two pumpkins, split the filling and béchamel between them. Poke a few holes down through the filling with the handle of a wooden spoon, then pour in the béchamel slowly, into the holes, until no more will go. Put the lid back on and bring the foil up to close over the top. Put any filling and béchamel that won't fit in the small ovenproof dish, with a pinch of the Emmental you're keeping for the top, to bake later.

    Aim: Filled nearly to the top, the béchamel poured in, the lid on, wrapped in foil.

    Ready when the béchamel has run down into the filling, the lid is on and the foil is closed at the top.

    Not yet confirmed: How much of the filling and béchamel the cavity takes: by my sums about a litre of the 1.3 litres, with the rest in the small dish.

    ovenproof dish5–8 minEstimate. My estimate.hands-on
    Watch Don't press the filling down, or the béchamel can't get in.
    If it goes wrong If the lid won't sit flat, cover the opening with a double layer of foil instead.
  16. 16
    The pumpkin. Straight after “Fill the pumpkin”

    Bake the pumpkin in foil

    Bake the wrapped pumpkin until a sharp knife passes easily through the skin.

    Aim: The pumpkin soft right through and the filling hot.

    Ready when a sharp knife pushed through the foil high on the shoulder, above the filling, slides through the skin with no resistance.

    Not yet confirmed: That the wrapped pumpkin holds its heat for half an hour if people are late: my estimate. How long it takes in foil: the source gives 1–1¼ hours for 3kg, but one dense 3kg pumpkin may need longer, and two medium ones may be done from 50 minutes.

    ovenproof dishoven, 200°C (180°C fan)60–75 minhands-off

    It can wait 30 minutes, in its foil.Estimate. A big pumpkin wrapped in foil holds its heat; this leaves room for a slow bake.

    Watch Two medium pumpkins may be done from 50 minutes; one dense 3kg pumpkin may need longer than 75. If people are late, leave it wrapped, where it holds its heat for about half an hour, and brown the top only once they're there.
    If it goes wrong If the knife meets resistance, bake it 15 minutes more, then test again.
  17. To serve. Just before serving.

    While the pumpkin bakes:

    17
    To serve. Any time from 3h 35 min to 1h 3 min before serving

    Slice the baguettes

    Slice the 3 baguettes into rounds about 1cm thick.

    Aim: Sliced baguette.

    board6–8 minEstimate. Three baguettes with a bread knife.hands-on

    It can wait 2 hours.Estimate. Prepared ingredients keep a couple of hours, covered.

  18. 18
    To serve. Any time from 2h 55 min to 55 min before serving

    Toast the baguette

    Toast the sliced baguette on baking trays in the oven while the pumpkin bakes, a tray at a time on the shelf that's free, for 8–12 minutes a tray, until crisp and lightly golden. Three baguettes fill four or five trays. If no shelf is free with the pumpkin in, toast before it goes in.

    Aim: Crisp slices for spreading.

    Ready when crisp and lightly golden.

    baking trayoven, 200°C (180°C fan)Estimate. The oven is already at 200°C for the pumpkin.35–50 minEstimate. 8–12 minutes a tray and four or five trays for three baguettes, one tray at a time beside the pumpkin.check every few minutes

    It can wait 2 hours, on the tray.Estimate. Toast keeps a couple of hours uncovered.

  19. 19
    The pumpkin. 35 min before serving

    Bake the overflow dish, if you have one

    If some filling didn't fit, put its dish in the oven beside the pumpkin and bake it until bubbling at the edges.

    Aim: The spare filling hot and bubbling, to spoon out alongside.

    Ready when bubbling at the edges.

    ovenproof dishoven, 200°C (180°C fan)Estimate. The oven is already at 200°C for the pumpkin.25–30 minEstimate. A shallow dish of cooked filling heats through in under half an hour; the source has no overflow dish.hands-off
  20. 20
    The pumpkin. 25 min before serving

    Brown the top

    Have ready: the baked pumpkin and the grated Emmental.

    Take the tin out and stand it on the hob or a board: it is heavy and very hot. Open the foil, away from you because of the steam, and fold it down into a collar round the pumpkin. Lift off the lid with tongs or a fish slice and discard it. Push a knife into the middle of the filling: if it comes out only warm, put the lid back, close the foil and bake it 15 minutes more before going on. Scatter the 25g of the grated Emmental over the filling and bake for 10 minutes more, until bubbling and bronzed. Let it sit for 10 minutes before serving, so the cheese settles.

    Aim: The cheese on top bubbling and bronzed.

    Ready when bubbling at the edges and bronzed on top.

    ovenproof dishoven, 200°C (180°C fan)10 min, then 10 min waitingEstimate. The source's 10 minutes; the rest is America's Test Kitchen's, which rests its stuffed pumpkin 15 minutes.check every few minutes
    If it goes wrong If it isn't bronzed after 10 minutes, give it 5 more.
  21. 21
    To serve

    Turn the oven off

    Turn the oven off.

  22. 22
    To serve. 5 min before serving

    Serve from the tin

    Have ready: the baked overflow dish and the toasted baguette.

    Tuck the foil collar down into the tin. Carry the tin to the table with oven gloves and set it on a trivet or board, with the toast, 220g cornichons and 240g salad leaves. Scoop the fondue out with some of the soft flesh from the sides, or spread it on the toast, with the cornichons alongside. If the pumpkin slumps or splits, the tin holds it.

    Aim: The pumpkin in its tin, with toast, cornichons and salad.

    ovenproof dish3–5 minhands-on

Notes

A Lyonnaise dish, which Meera Sodha adapted after seeing Anthony Bourdain eat it on television at Daniel Boulud's parents' farmhouse. Use one large pumpkin or two medium ones: what matters is the size of the cavity, not the weight. Bake it in the tin you'll serve from, because a baked pumpkin is soft and heavy to move. To get ahead, make the onion and mushroom mix the day before, chill it, and warm it through in the sauté pan before folding in the cheese. The original uses vegetarian cheeses; Gruyère and Emmental are usually made with animal rennet, so buy ones labelled vegetarian if that matters to a guest.