Carrot steak with lemony hollandaise

Thin salted carrot ribbons rolled into a log, charred hard, then basted in butter until the layers loosen, with a very sharp hollandaise.

From Kevin Kroløkke (Doobydobap), after Relæ, Copenhagen: What my ex-Michelin trained chef husband cooks in a week. Rewritten in my own words.

In development: changed, not cooked as written yet29 amounts, times and temperatures are estimates, marked est. where they appear. Tap one to see why.
Serves
2 big starters or small mains
Takes
1h 51 min, start to serving
Hands-on
about 1h 25 min, plus 29 min with a pan or the oven to watch
Oven
220°C (200°C fan), only in caseEstimate. Half Batch Baking finishes its carrot steaks in a 425°F oven, about 220°C; Kevin's video only says to finish in the oven.

Not yet confirmed

No source or cook has confirmed these yet, so watch them as you cook.

  • The garlic in the baste: left out by mistake on the first cook (Baste the steaks until tender)
  • How long the char takes: not timed on the first cook (Char the logs)

When to make each part

Latest start to servingCan start this much earlierHands-on, at a set timeHands-on, any time in this range

  • Carrot steaksStart by 1h 51 min before serving, 1h 2 min hands-on.
  • HollandaiseStart by 22 min before serving, 18 min hands-on.
  • To serveJust before serving, 2 min hands-on.

This is one possible order. Each step only has to come after the steps it uses.

  1. Cook through to serving

    Carrot steaks. Start at least 1h 51 min before serving. Keeps 15 minutes, in the pan.

    1
    Carrot steaks. 1h 51 min before serving

    Peel the carrots

    Peel the carrots. The 600g carrots is what you want once they're peeled and sliced.

    Aim: Peeled carrots.

    board4–5 minhands-on

    Pause point: it keeps 2 hours.Estimate. Prepared ingredients keep a couple of hours, covered.

  2. 2
    Carrot steaks. 1h 46 min before serving

    Slice the carrots into ribbons

    Slice the peeled carrots lengthwise into ribbons about 1mm thick.

    Aim: Long, even ribbons, about 1mm thick.

    Ready when you can almost see through them.

    board6–8 minhands-on
    Safety A guard can't hold a carrot lengthwise, so stop while there's still a good piece to hold. The last thin slice isn't worth a fingertip.
  3. 3
    Carrot steaks. 1h 38 min before serving

    Salt the ribbons

    Toss the ribbons with the 6g fine salt and leave them. Tip away the liquid, then pat the ribbons dry with kitchen paper until they're no longer slippery, so they hold together when you roll.

    Aim: Floppy ribbons, seasoned through and patted dry.

    Ready when the ribbons bend without snapping.

    bowl2 min, then 3–5 min waitingEstimate. Half Batch Baking salts for about 2 minutes; thicker ribbons take longer.hands-on
    Taste Taste a ribbon. It should taste well seasoned. Don't rinse it, because the salt left on the ribbons seasons the steak.
  4. 4
    Carrot steaks. 1h 31 min before serving

    Roll the ribbons into logs

    Layer the ribbons and tightly into logs, one per person, using long ribbons only: short ones pop out as you roll. Go slowly; a log that starts to come apart can be pushed back together. Tie each with twine in two places, or it may fall apart in the pan (it stays on through the cooking and comes off just before serving), then leave them to settle.

    Aim: Tight logs that hold their shape.

    Ready when they hold their shape when you let go.

    board20–30 min, then 10–15 min waitinghands-on

    Pause point: it keeps 2 hours, covered.Estimate. Rolled raw carrot holds its shape for a couple of hours.

    If it goes wrong If a log starts to come apart, unroll the loose end, press the ribbons back flat and roll it up again, then tie it.
  5. 5
    Carrot steaks. Any time from 1h 51 min to 48 min before serving

    Crush the garlic

    Crush the 3–4 garlic cloves with the flat of a knife, skins on.

    Aim: Crushed garlic cloves.

    board1–2 minEstimate. A few cloves under the flat of a knife.hands-on

    Pause point: it keeps 2 hours.Estimate. Prepared ingredients keep a couple of hours, covered.

  6. 6
    Carrot steaks. 46 min before serving

    Char the logs

    Have ready: the carrot logs.

    Heat the 30ml vegetable oil in a large frying pan until it shimmers. Stand the logs on one flat spiral end and them hard, then turn them onto the other end and do the same. Nothing is cut: the ends are the rolled spirals.

    Aim: Black in places on both ends. A raw centre is fine.

    Ready when both ends are black in places and smoking.

    Not yet confirmed: How long the char takes: not timed on the first cook.

    frying panhob, high heat10–14 minEstimate. My estimate; the video doesn't time it.hands-on

    It can wait 30 minutes.Estimate. They go on to cook for 20–30 minutes in the baste, so a short wait does no harm.

    Watch Don't move them while they colour.
  7. 7
    Carrot steaks. 32 min before serving

    Baste the steaks until tender

    Have ready: the crushed garlic cloves.

    Turn the heat down to medium-low and give the pan a minute to cool, so the butter foams but never browns. Add the 60–80g unsalted butter, thyme sprigs (a few sprigs) and the crushed garlic cloves, and them often.

    Aim: Tender all the way through, the layers loosening, the outside very dark.

    Ready when a knife slides through and the layers start to loosen. The outside should be very dark.

    Not yet confirmed: The garlic in the baste: left out by mistake on the first cook.

    frying panhob, medium-low heat20–30 mincheck every few minutes
    Note Two logs fit an ordinary 28cm pan. For 3 or 4, use a bigger pan or split them between two pans, so they're all ready together.
    If it isn't ready. The outside is very dark but the centre still resists the knife. In the pan, if it's ovenproof: Cover the pan with foil and put it in the oven. 220°C (200°C fan), 4–6 min.In an ovenproof dish: Move the steaks and their butter to an ovenproof dish, cover it with foil and put it in the oven. 220°C (200°C fan), 4–6 min.
  8. 8
    Carrot steaks

    Heat the oven

    About 5 minutes into “Baste the steaks until tender”, heat the oven to 220°C (200°C fan) in case you need it.Estimate. Half Batch Baking finishes its carrot steaks in a 425°F oven, about 220°C; Kevin's video only says to finish in the oven.

    15 min
  9. Hollandaise. Start at least 22 min before serving. Keeps 30 minutes, over warm water, whisked now and then.

    9
    Hollandaise. Any time from 1h 51 min to 22 min before serving

    Separate the eggs

    Separate the 2 eggs, putting the yolks in a heatproof bowl and the whites in a small bowl. Cover the yolks.

    Aim: The yolks in a heatproof bowl.

    heatproof bowl2 minEstimate. My estimate.hands-on

    Pause point: it keeps 90 minutes, covered.Estimate. Raw yolks are safe out of the fridge for up to 2 hours (USDA's two-hour rule); 90 minutes leaves room.

  10. While the steaks baste:

    10
    Hollandaise. Any time from 1h 47 min to 20 min before serving

    Melt the butter

    Melt the 125g unsalted butter in a small pan, then take it off the heat. It should be warm, not hot, when it goes into the yolks.

    Aim: Melted and warm, not hot.

    Ready when fully melted.

    saucepanhob, lowest heat3 minEstimate. My estimate.hands-on

    Pause point: it keeps an hour, off the heat; warm it again for a moment if it starts to set.Estimate. Melted butter stays liquid for a good while off the heat, and left on a ring it ends up hot.

  11. 11
    Hollandaise. Any time from 1h 51 min to 17 min before serving

    Juice the lemon

    Juice the lemon.

    Aim: Lemon juice.

    board1–2 minEstimate. One lemon by hand.hands-on

    Pause point: it keeps 2 hours.Estimate. Prepared ingredients keep a couple of hours, covered.

  12. 12
    Hollandaise. Any time from 54 min to 15 min before serving

    Whisk the yolks over heat

    Bring a little water to a bare simmer in a small pan, set the bowl over it, not touching the water (a ), and whisk the 2 egg yolks with a splash of water.

    Aim: Pale and thickened, like loose custard.

    Ready when pale and thickened, like loose custard.

    heatproof bowlhob, barely simmering4–5 minEstimate. My estimate.hands-on
    Watch If the edges start to set, lift the bowl off the heat and keep whisking.
  13. 13
    Hollandaise. Straight after “Whisk the yolks over heat”

    Whisk in the butter

    Have ready: the melted butter.

    Off the heat, whisk in the melted butter slowly until it emulsifies.

    Aim: A thick, glossy sauce.

    Ready when the butter is all taken in and the sauce is thick and glossy.

    heatproof bowl4–5 minEstimate. My estimate.hands-on
    If it goes wrong If it splits and looks greasy, whisk a spoonful of hot water in a clean bowl, then whisk the split sauce into it a little at a time.
  14. 14
    Hollandaise. Straight after “Whisk in the butter”

    Season the hollandaise

    Have ready: the lemon juice.

    Season with the lemon juice and fine salt.

    Aim: Glossy, pourable and sharp.

    Ready when almost too sour, enough to make you pucker a little.

    heatproof bowl1 minEstimate. My estimate.hands-on
    Taste It has to cut the sweet carrot, so add lemon until it is almost too sour.
  15. 15
    Hollandaise

    Keep the hollandaise warm

    Keep the hollandaise warm, over warm water, whisked now and then. Keeps 30 minutes.Estimate. The recipe says keep warm and use within 30 minutes.

  16. 16
    Carrot steaks

    Turn the oven off

    Turn the oven off if you didn't need it.

  17. To serve. Just before serving.

    17
    To serve. 2 min before serving

    Plate up

    Have ready: the carrot steaks.

    Snip and pull off any twine, then serve each steak whole or halved, a charred end up, with the hollandaise alongside.

    Aim: Hot steaks and warm sauce, straight away.

    plates2 minEstimate. My estimate.hands-on

Leftovers

Put the egg whites, covered, in the fridge. Keeps 3 days.Estimate. Raw egg whites keep 2–4 days covered in the fridge.

Notes

Kevin's method, with the cooking order from Relæ's original (charred black, then basted gently in butter) and carrot choice from Half Batch Baking's version. Don't rinse the salt off, push the colour much darker than feels right, and make the hollandaise sharp enough to balance the sweet carrot.